Since its first year of NCAA Division I competition in 1981, UTSA Athletics boasts more than 80 conference championships, over 60 NCAA team postseason appearances and 70 All-Americans, among numerous other accolades and memorable moments. To celebrate its rich history, the department launched the UTSA Athletics Hall of Fame in 2023. 

UTSA's inaugural Hall of Fame Class featured McKenzie Adams (volleyball/women’s basketball), Devin Brown (men’s basketball), Marcus Davenport (football) and Tameka Roberts (track & field/women’s basketball), as well as former head football coach Larry Coker and former athletics director Lynn Hickey. 

The 2024 Hall of Fame Class included Derrick Gervin (men's basketball), Monica Gibbs (women's basketball), Michael Rockett (baseball), Starlite Williams (women's basketball/women's track & field) and Teddy Williams (men's track & field). 

The 2025 Hall of Fame Class is made up of Fabiola Arriaga (women’s golf), Rudy Davalos (administration), Amanda Michalsky (softball) and Mark Schramek (baseball). They will be enshrined in October.